The most expensive employee you can hire

Blog: Expensive employees – how to avoid them

expensive employee - How to use an assessment matrix

What is the most expensive employee you can hire?

It is a Category 3 employee.  The trick is to spot them and eliminate them during the recruitment process.   My best advice is to use an Assessment Matrix.  Firstly, what is an expensive employee?

Risk and why someone is an expensive employee

Recruitment is all about minimising the risk of hiring the wrong person.

Essentially, there are four types of candidates:

  1. The unsuitables: easy to eliminate in the recruitment process; an entry level junior can do this for you.
  2. The maybes: they may have the right personality but lack experience.  You could train them up, however, there is a higher risk associated with taking them on board.
  3. The look good: resume and experience are of interest.  Interview – fantastic.  Testing and reference checks – fantastic.  We hire them … and we wish we had not.
  4. Then there is the one: looks great and is brilliant in the job.  They excel and they stay.

The difficulty in recruiting is separating a category 3 from a category 4 because they both perform superbly in the interviews.  They both look like High Achievers.

Category 3’s are the expensive employees.

Their performance is not disastrous yet continuously unsatisfactory and regularly below par, however, not bad enough to warrant a termination.  Therefore, they have a high opportunity cost.  It is ongoing as they stay with the organisation for years.  They are truly expensive employees because they continue to underperform.

How to avoid hiring expensive category 3 employees?

Next time you recruit, I recommend the use of an Assessment Matrix.  The Assessment Matrix is the “recruitment blueprint”, and is simple to set up.

Most expensive employee you can hire - Assessment Matrix

The selection criteria are listed on the left side, with the stages of the recruitment process heading the following columns.  Selection criteria are used to assess the candidates’ suitability for your role.

Each candidate should address the selection criteria at least once during the process, however, it is better to have multiple, independent sets of verification – also known as double and triple checking.  For example, if three independent observations (initial phone screening, interview, and reference checking) are obtained that all lead to the same conclusion, then the risk is minimised.

A candidate with two positive and one negative observation is not necessarily unsuitable, however, the risk is higher for that selection criteria.  The philosophy is to minimise the risk for across all selection criteria through individual observations.

If using a recruitment agency, this is the least that should be expected.  Ask the consultant to detail their process and the Assessment Matrix. If it can’t be shown to you, you have the right to question if you are getting value for money.

Download an Assessment Matrix template for your personal use:

See also: Why cover letters suck

11 Recruitment - Christian Madsen - Behaviour

Christian Madsen
Managing Director
11 Recruitment

LinkedIn Profile

To receive my next blog just click Subscribe

  • Frank Kennedy says:

    Great article Christian. Spot on with the candidate types and a very good solution provided to find the ideal employee.

  • Related posts

    Testing data
    HTML Content Options

    Focus ahead

    When I talk to CEOs and Managing Directors they don't talk much about cost savings anymore. That activity has run its course. Most companies are much leaner now than 5 years ago.  There is not much more to be gained by focusing on costs. They are now talking about how to increase revenue. Hire more people. Different type of people - people with different skills.Therefore, some people might need to "retool" themselves. Either formally or doing it at home in front of the PC. YouTube is for many the best tutor in the world along with Google. It is possible to learn almost anything with a determined effort to gain knowledge. Along with increased competencies often come not only job opportunities but also pay rise and increased job satisfaction and a lot more.

    Job market - Perth WA - looking better

    So, it might not be party time yet - but we should be some better times ahead of us... Scaling Options
    >